Chartered Engineering

CBIC Circular 07/2020 explained: how Customs values second-hand machinery

A practical summary of CBIC Circular 07/2020-Customs on valuing imported second-hand machinery and the role of empanelled Chartered Engineers.

By Techkrate Editorial TeamUpdated 4 min read

Key takeaways

  • CBIC Circular No. 07/2020-Customs, dated 5 February 2020, sets out how Customs values imported second-hand machinery. It superseded Circular 25/2015.
  • Custom Houses were directed to empanel Chartered Engineers for appraisal and valuation of second-hand machinery.
  • Once a Custom House has empanelled engineers, the earlier practice of accepting certification from pre-shipment inspection agencies for valuation is discontinued.
  • The engineer’s report is part of the import declaration, so its evidence and reasoning must hold up to scrutiny.

When second-hand machinery arrives at an Indian port, Customs has to decide its value for duty purposes. Used machines have no catalogue price, and invoice values for used goods can be hard to verify. To address this, the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs issued Circular No. 07/2020-Customs on 5 February 2020, setting out how Custom Houses should approach the valuation of second-hand machinery.

This article summarises the circular’s practical effect. It is general information. Refer to the circular and the relevant Custom House public notices for exact requirements.

Why the circular exists

The circular responded to representations from trade about its predecessor, Circular 25/2015-Customs. It aimed to give a consistent framework for appraising and valuing used machinery across Custom Houses, with qualified engineers providing the technical assessment that valuation depends on.

Empanelment of Chartered Engineers

A central feature of the circular is that each Custom House should empanel Chartered Engineers who meet the circular’s requirements, for the purpose of appraising and valuing second-hand machinery. Custom Houses across the country followed with public notices inviting applications, for example Kandla, Chennai, Mumbai and New Delhi in 2020, with further rounds in later years.

Custom Houses that already had empanelled engineers could continue with them under the terms of their empanelment, unless requirements dictated otherwise. Pre-shipment inspection agencies with the requisite qualifications could also apply for empanelment.

The end of PSIA certification for valuation

The circular clarified that once a Custom House has empanelled Chartered Engineers, the practice of accepting certification from pre-shipment inspection agencies for the valuation of second-hand machinery is discontinued. In effect, valuation reports for second-hand machinery came to rest on qualified engineers recognised for the purpose.

The report as part of the import declaration

Formats annexed to the circular indicate that the engineer’s certificate is presented by the importer to Indian Customs as part of the import declaration under the Customs Act, 1962, which is a legal declaration. The formats also require the engineer to enclose evidence of the qualification that entitles them to perform the appraisal.

That matters for practices. A certificate that forms part of a legal declaration needs a clear evidential basis. Customs orders available publicly show inspection reports being examined in detail, including the year of manufacture, specifications and condition recorded by the engineer.

What a defensible appraisal looks like

Without going beyond what the circular requires, good practice for an appraisal report usually includes:

  • clear identification of each item, including make, model, serial number and year of manufacture as found
  • photographs that tie each observation to the item it describes
  • a description of condition supported by evidence
  • the valuation approach used and the reasoning behind the figure
  • consistency checks between the physical findings and the import documents.

Each element should be traceable. If an officer asks how the year of manufacture was established, the nameplate photo should be in the file. If the value is questioned, the workings should be there. We expand on this in building traceable evidence into Chartered Engineer reports.

Practical tips for empanelled practices

Practices working under a Custom House panel often share the same operational lessons.

  • Keep empanelment documents current. Qualifications, registrations and any documents the Custom House requires should be up to date and easy to produce.
  • Respond quickly to allocation. Importers face port charges while goods wait, so a reliable process for scheduling inspections matters.
  • Use a consistent report structure. Officers who see the same structure from a practice every time can review it faster.
  • Record discrepancies plainly. Where physical findings differ from documents, say so clearly. Hidden or softened discrepancies damage credibility.
  • Keep the evidence. Officers, importers or appellate bodies may ask questions long after clearance.

Each Custom House may add its own procedures through public notices, so practices working at several ports should track the notices that apply at each one.

Implications for Chartered Engineering practices

Empanelled practices often handle many consignments at once, at different ports, under time pressure from importers facing port charges. The combination of volume, deadlines and legal weight is what makes organisation so important. Evidence captured by site staff needs to reach the engineer intact, linked to the right item, with nothing lost in chat threads or personal phones.

CARS, Techkrate’s platform for Chartered Engineering practices, is designed around that need. It keeps photos, documents, observations and valuation workings in one record per consignment and generates reports in the practice’s own format after the engineer’s review. It is not a Customs system and does not determine value. Find out more on the CARS page.

Frequently asked questions

Who can be empanelled as a Chartered Engineer by Customs?

Each Custom House invites applications against the eligibility requirements in the circular and its own public notice. Requirements typically include recognised professional qualifications and experience in appraising machinery. Check the public notice issued by the relevant Custom House.

Does the Chartered Engineer decide the customs value?

No. Customs determines the assessable value. The Chartered Engineer provides an inspection and appraisal report that Customs uses in that determination.

What should an appraisal report for Customs include?

Clear identification of each item (make, model, serial number and year), its condition and residual life, the basis of valuation with workings, and photographs tied to each item. Customs relies on that report as one input when it determines value.

Can Custom House procedures differ from the circular?

Yes. The circular sets the framework, and individual Custom Houses issue public notices on empanelment and procedure. Check the current circular and the public notice of the port of import before each consignment.

Regulatory references were checked at the time of writing. Rules change, so confirm against the current official text before relying on them. This article is general information, not legal advice.

See where Techkrate fits your practice.

Leave your work email and we will set up a walkthrough of MOVAL or CARS using work like yours.

We use your email only to arrange the walkthrough. See our Privacy Policy.